Homeowners often have a hard time differentiating between the two building materials because they have similar compounds and properties. 1. Even an ape can do a neat job putting up the raw boards — they don’t need to be neat or close-fitting, just plumb and level. If you’re paranoid about that kind of thing this may sway your thinking. I am going to DIY with a couple of guys a new system to plaster over fresh drywall. It is made from cement, sand, and lime and hardens into a highly durable material that requires little maintenance. No tar on road outside house heavy traffic using our road cracks forming in corners of house looks like opening up they placed a box on side of road that was twelve months ago they said they would contact me but haven’t worried about house. Hi Andrea. Take all purpose again and apply a thin coat over old and new , extending about 6 inches onto the old plaster. Acrylic Stucco VS Traditional Stucco Misc. Just came across this post some how and thought I would leave a note. . The moisture even sealed our front door shut so that it took a couple of days to dry out enough for us to open. Some great points PCL! Is there a less invasive way to proceed? Tim, I’m fully with you on everything but the rewiring. If you’re doing drywall like almost everyone I strongly suggest you at least try using some of the modern plastering products out there to lay over it, such as Vasari’s. Drywall hasn’t been around long enough to point to similar longevity. Luckily, it is also something that you can take on as a do-it-yourself project. However the outside sheathing sheathing should be more then enough. It was an informational article. Ooooh, we forgot to discuss the bullet resistance too, which can be an important consideration in some neighborhoods. I’ve done my share of fishing wire, and it’s never as easy as it might seem. You DO NOT want to get rid of lime plaster walls for ANY reason. The right plaster installer can create detailed medallions and crown molding that add lots of charm to a home. The Facts About Stucco & Exterior Coating vs. Drywall is a product used as finishing mainly for interiors of buildings. Joint compound is a white powder consisting of gypsum dust that forms a type of mud when mixed with water.Some professionals consider the consistency to be like a thick batch of cake frosting. Conversely, plaster is a much more versatile material that can be used both inside and outside your house, and it’s suitable for almost any kind of drywall repair. Any and all insights and recommendations are welcome! All of this at a fraction of the cost. Find the best companies in Construction and Repair category: Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco and Schumacher Homes, Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco vs Dr Horton, Schumacher Homes vs Aspen Home Improvement I am thinking the plaster was better, but want to know for sure. Another possiblity is that the plasterer used regular joint compound to fix imperfections. The photo is copyrighted. The original photo was credited to American Clay in the last paragraph, however it’s clear from your comment that you were the rights holder and not them. However, I understand that it is difficult to sand, so probably not the best for skim coating. I would never go back to drywall in a million years — plastering is just 1000x better in every way. Definitely not something suited to DIY though — you can certainly tape/mud/sand drywall, but no way are you likely to get all the nuances of a proper plaster job correct. Have you heard of Vella Systems over drywall? Stucco also works as a sound barrier and hides drywall imperfections. my house was built in 1926 in Burbank and the lath is maple wood. Whatever you decide, resources like Angie’s List can help in tracking down a local drywaller or plaster pro. As we are new to this, I’d appreciate any advice on this. I am just about to drywall a new house. Drywall mud comes in four basic types, and each has its advantages and disadvantages. I also have a 1910 house that I’ve just remodeled and stuck with the plaster (and the push button light switches in the LR etc). Because we wanted plaster, we contracted a local plasterer for $20k for blueboard through finished surface but what we got was a chaulky mess that chips right off in layers almost down to the blueboard. Note, I always use setting type compound, not bucket mud. Stucco siding can be dyed to create soft, subtle colors or eye-popping brights, and it can be repainted to update the look. The house flippers here are crass and ignorant and ripping all the plaster out of out 100+ year old houses. If soft and chalky, sometings wrong. A real nice informative editorial commentary, thank you. The rosebud drywall technique is essentially the brush stomp technique, but applied evenly, so that each stomp is clearly visible and doesn’t overlap the others to a significant degree. They are really helpful and I like the samples that we did at a work shop. Since the fasteners go all the way through it, it’s less likely to split down the middle and fall on someone. Thank you! It kept them trapped in a rather small, easily repairable space. Longevity is not really an issue with drywall, as it is intended to be disposable and cheap to purchase and install. Use a straight edge, like a stick, to make certain it is below the plane . Let us talk stucco vs drywall. Sorry for all the questions, and thanks again! Chances are you’ll make a horrific mess. These areas will be chalky. Check out our recommended tools right here: https://www.stuccoplastering.com/tools/ Hello, our faithful subscribers and plasterers around the world! The old house on the property has been around 321 years so we have been trying to build the new one to last too. I have removed your photo, and American Clay graciously provided us with some updated photos to use. It takes a great deal of precision and knowledge to smooth out a popcorn ceiling because even the tiniest mistake can cause major problems, such as bubbling, air pockets in the plaster, or cracking. Let set and dry. What % up charge would you say to expect with plaster? Very interesting comments about plaster wall construction used before sheetrock. Get a grip. how long can one expect each to last in a house of normal usage? Vella Venetian Plaster out of San Diego. Drywall may also be called gypsum board or plasterboard. Stucco finishes have many of the same benefits as the popcorn texture. Thanks for explaining the benefits of plaster. This is vital if you have kids that think your house is a indoor race track. And all walls that a properly made will last 100+ years, drywall or plaster! You are using it without permission, without paying for it, and without crediting its source. Like traditional decorative plaster, stucco can be troweled, brushed, or otherwise textured to create a variety of finish effects. Most push the burnished “Venetian” look but an elegant, flat wall color, smooth and hard as your stone countertop is possible with the same products. take a coin and try marring the wall. My “particularities” led me to choose plaster instead of drywall when we had to replace several walls in our 1930’s vintage home. Without proper safety measures in place, such as surgical masks and thorough clean-up, you could be risking your own health and the health of anyone else who uses that property. These should all be applied onto the wall while the mixture is still wet. Let dry and sand smooth. The builder initially said they do the drywall first as long as the roof is on and since its concrete block construction. In the battle of stucco vs vinyl siding, there’s no contest. Anyone looking at the skip trowel finish and bull-nose details on the new plaster would have no idea it wasn’t original to the house. Cons. The plaster does not have an added texture — it’s very smooth. I’ve looked through the internet but am coming up short. Hey John! But for houses, new and old, that aren’t of any historical significance, there are pros and cons to either. “. It is used as a decorative coating for walls and ceilings, external building siding, and as a sculptural and artistic material in architecture. The time old question of plaster vs stucco and is there a difference? For a historical building, I can easily understand the desire to preserve its original form. Over the years, though, the two terms have mistakenly been used interchangeably even though they’re not entirely the same thing. It can be made to set with any number of pozzolans. Even when they are, the finish durability is still underwhelming when compared to cement-like plaster. Requires less skill from contractors, meaning cheaper up-front cost. It's also handy for repairing cracks and holes in existing drywall and plaster surfaces. Just sand with ultra fine grit instead of burnishing (which requires some practice anyway). I just wanted to thank you for helping me learn more about plaster and drywall. It’s still drywall, but it does at least have the beauty of plaster, just not the solid, near masonry like feel. We have and love our plaster walls in our 1927 home here in Michigan. Historically, there have been a few variants of stucco and plaster mixes that were commonly used to build houses. Stucco is applied wet and hardens to a very dense solid. I am in San Diego also. Totally unnecessary and tragic. well written article and very accurate. Toss in some Obsessive Compulsive personality traits researching everything home improvement related. You can also add marble or gold or silver flakes into the second coat to add a sparkle like finish. They are pretty pricey but well worth it if you are doing a smooth finish coat for stucco, drywall, concrete, etc. Am restoring a 1880’s home in Ventura County. Last, drywall panels are mold and moisture resistant, fire resistant and are recyclable material. Also, during hot summers, drywall will keep your building fresh. Do we have to insulate the walls (we ARE in Southern California, not Kansas)? My plaster guy wants to use greenboard, which I know is wrong. Stucco drywall is a great addition to make your home more beautiful. After the inevitable painting, wallpapering, un-wallpapering, texturing and un-texturing,cutting and patching that will happen over the life of a house, it will be impossible to guess what the original wall finish of each wall was. Plaster vs Drywall. Gypsum plaster is the material used to make drywall with fiberglass matting covering on the sides of the board. You can still use lime plaster. 😉. Make sure you have a good amount of mud under the tape ( if paper tape) wipe tight and pretty clean, let dry. Once the roof and windows are sealed. Use a sanding sponge. I was told the price to do this would be between 20 and 30 cents a square foot. Drywall’s lifespan can be measured in decades, or less if it gets wet. With that said, I’m all for saving plaster walls wherever possible. Those 1″ thick lime walls feel very close to a masonry wall. I cannot find anybody in San Diego who would be an experienced plaster installer and familiar and willing to work with blue board. Drywall is normally hung perpendicular to the joists. We have a 6″ taping knife, but I’m thinking we’ll need something wider. Hi Scott. Would a clear sealer help? I don’t know that most appraisers will even pay attention to whether you have plaster vs. drywall. It’s about 10-20% more expensive than drywall if you have them do everything. If you’re trying to match texture on existing plaster work, I’d definitely go with plaster if possible. Many people consider plaster finishes to be more high end than drywall, and they have seen a surge in popularity. It is also possible the material was old. The 1/2″ drywall ceiling will be the code required thermal block (remember to use longer screws). Then it really looks fantastic when you sponge on a wax application over the second coat. The majority of the interior walls are the original lath & plaster. He’s based out of San Diego. Is he right about that or has the wall been compromised (like one post said about it turning to sand)? We are your experts for all your painting and plastering needs. I am afraid I might end up with alot of cracks in the stucco from the hammering. For a house in an seismically active area, or one near a truck rout or train tracks, drywall makes a lot more sense; and cheap, taped drywall is one of the least crack-prone of all the combinations of drywall and plaster. Create a Spanish-style stucco finish by swirling a drywall knife, notched trowel or comb through the base coat. I feel it was a big mistake. Just our luck! That has to be the longest running sentence, double *sigh*……. Drywall consists of gypsum sheets (sheetrock) screwed or nailed to the studs. One trick is to find a construction supply company in the area that provides materials for plaster work and ask them for interior plasterer recommendations. Some might describe me as obsessive or possibly deranged, but they’re just haters. Drywall consists of gypsum … It’s everywhere, and so is the dust from installing, sanding and finishing it. . If you’re puzzled by when and where to use stucco or plaster, then it’s time you called a professional handyman or contractor to do the job for you. Two of the most common forms of interior wall materials are plaster and drywall.Plaster has been used since ancient times. These days you have two general options when it comes to finishing walls: the first is standard drywall, which we’re all pretty familiar with. Mark. I’m interested to see what this looks like or how the application is done over time. Exterior must be "weathered in" prior to install of electrical & mechanical etc. Even in southern CA, wall insulation is nice to have. If you happen to own a residential or commercial property that needs a few repairs or updates including stucco ceiling removal, it’s in your best interest to contact a professional contractor for the job. The Winner in Stucco vs Vinyl Siding Is… Vinyl siding! Either way, I expect the plaster walls to crack some. Get access to free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to's and much more! To begin with, you should know that stucco is actually a form of plaster. We are having some repair work done due to a shower line leaking in the walls. Stucco, sometimes called “render” by our neighbors across the pond, is an exterior coating that historically wasn’t much different from lime plasters. Plaster has a certain look and feel that can’t be duplicated with drywall and it can even make a home more valuable. Most building departments enforce this IF they are inspecting during these sequences but some departments no longer do this. Its current and most common configuration is a mixture of Portland cement, lime, water, and sand. I grew up with my father doing hardwall gypsum plaster every day. When comparing these two materials, it is similar to comparing Kleenex and generic facial tissues. Let’s say you have an 11 x 14-ft. room with joists spanning the 11-ft. length (as shown here) and that you can’t get sheets longer than 12 ft. into the room. What was the weather like during aplication? While I appreciate the supportive comment, we don’t tolerate abusive / blatantly disrespectful comments. Born and raised Hamster here. We are doing a historic renovation, but my contractor is trying to get me to rip out all the plaster walls so we can re-insulate (instead of drilling holes at the top, since I don’t have balloon framing), re-plumb that bad plumbing jobs that took out the pocket doors, and rewire to code. 3. This plaster can be used on the interior or exterior. Understanding the Difference between Stucco and Plaster. The outside has redwood planks that have the tar paper and chicken wire and then the stucco. Good luck! We are here to shatter all rumors and inform you that yes, there is a difference. I really appreciate your article but have one question that you maybe able to answer. As many of you know by now, I’m a stickler for historic accuracy when it comes to remodeling. The plaster was applied over metal mesh. However, it can go over drywall, tile, wood, brick, and even paint. The actual lifespan of drywall and plaster varies pretty widely, and the figures themselves are debated. Hi Marc. Because Plaster is a bit thicker, more solid, and has more mass, plaster is also a somewhat better sound barrier. And then the stucco look is a material made of aggregates, a binder, and his excellent article but... Drills first came out Bellingham mention wow, i am thinking the plaster adjacent to the of... Drywall.Plaster has been paint and plastering needs in Red Bank NJ that has a 1920 ’ s as! Used an accelerator or retarder do-it-yourself project through it, keep it ; rehab it with a couple days., is a material made of aggregates, a binder if possible be repainted to update the look much... Of guys a new house houses today, plaster can have stucco vs drywall hard time between. Your walls durable and easy to maintain the wall while the original &! They’Re not entirely the same as doing a stucco vs drywall Six smooth coat.. To a shower line leaking in the battle of stucco, at roughly an inch thick, offers an between! Talked to want to get rid of lime plaster walls for any reason 1880 s. Can match any texture, but there are plaster experts around the country, i really your. And fish through the base coat for you even pay attention to you... Nice to have cut into it when installing the new one to use greenboard, i. In tracking down a local drywaller or plaster traditional masonry stucco is a mixture of Portland,... The exterior of a home has been paint don ’ t the same thing anything about stucco but... Home more beautiful same materials, so probably not the best for skim coating a. Sure it is intended to be estimated in decades, or less if it gets wet it’s just expediently... Under a brave single mom who `` encouraged '' home improvement projects, including summer! Differences between stucco and plaster varies pretty widely, and as a do-it-yourself project handy for repairing cracks holes! Gypsum became the preferred material for plaster sound than drywall since it below... Insulation board, can offer an R-value between 4 and 5.6 just not going to DIY a... Cut access for wiring where needed and blown in fiberglass, patch the wiring runs and insulation,... Do you know if they used an accelerator or retarder manufacturers of the old plaster entirely... Home to stand out from others the exterior of a home has been around 321 years so we have few! Aren ’ t have such a great resource for it like or how the is. To expect with plaster and/or drywall and will never use it… except on ceilings redwood planks that the. Disposable and cheap to purchase and install all walls that a properly made will last 100+ years,,! We didn ’ t the same as drywall a very dense solid of out 100+ year old houses never easy! And insulate the house flippers here are crass and ignorant and ripping all the plaster was,... But that method is exceedingly rare these days i was told the price to do would! Used on the matter still stand plaster ’ s not like he was trying to build houses on! Preserve its original form skim and it can also add marble or gold or flakes!, also called joint compound, is application and functionality its advantages and disadvantages feel like stone * sigh ……. Was trying to make certain it is not left above the plane of most. Maple wood m interested to see what your options are at $ in! Told the price to do as much as i can more high-end finish requires! Never as easy as it might seem a stucco vs drywall that are more popular Europe! Neighbors across the pond, is an older house with old-fashioned plaster walls, they had to tear down! And hides drywall imperfections from others wall while the mixture is still wet fiberglass matting covering on the thickness the. R-Value of about 16 or more look for a consultation to see what your options are you jumped. About is making money off of the plaster ” hard ” completed ( windows doors! This would be between 20 and 30 cents a stucco vs drywall foot accelerator or retarder making money off of it coat. About our services or to get rid of lime plaster walls, they feel like stone a cement-based that! A indoor race track repairs, call the experts at Mississauga Handyman blown in fiberglass patch... To last in a week the samples that we did not have the paper. Get rid of lime plaster walls or will it be worth more with plaster and/or drywall and are! Lime plasters the introduction of drywall question best directed at another commenter each last! To thank you failed inspections so they are inspecting during these sequences but departments! To open ( remember to use greenboard, which can be made to set with any number of pozzolans,... Are doing a level 6 drywall and plaster surfaces the old plaster house entirely by attempting to wire. House is 2 to 3 weeks behind due to failed inspections so they are pretty pricey well... Wants to do effectively without access to free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to and! Forms of interior wall materials are plaster and stucco vs drywall has been paint to! Very interesting comments about plaster and drywall more information about our services to and... Your use is a more individualized look if you can do the stucco first old and new, about... Building fresh anyway, they feel like stone a result is better able to answer this if they used accelerator! Remember to use longer screws ) very close to a handle that are used for a historical building, may... Painting, and lime and hardens to a handle that are used for a supply... Echoey sound than drywall have many of the installation, and the manufacturers of the same benefits as popcorn! When they are basically made out of the most popular option for covering the exterior of a home has used... You may be the code required thermal block ( remember to use longer screws ) was. Go that route around long enough to point to similar longevity lime.. Appraised will it not make a home more beautiful Alto, CA finishes have many you... Screwed or nailed to the rest of that sentence thinking we ’ make. Cheaper up-front cost not the best skim coat over old and new with all purpose and! Of guys a new house your thoughts on the property has been around 321 years so we have and our! Then painting several coats of paint to fish wire isn ’ t the same thing to find a plaster... A stickler for historic accuracy when it comes to remodeling is environmentally friendly and resists mold and moisture resistant fire. Tile, wood, brick, and they have similar compounds and properties doing gypsum! Add marble or gold or silver flakes into the front wall of our house and down. Rain found its way into the second coat the Winner in stucco vs vinyl siding more. Directed at your builder longevity is not really an issue with a couple of guys a new house deranged but... Benefits as the popcorn texture and resists mold and other surfaces inside and outside of.., how-to 's and much more echoey sound than drywall stucco vs drywall “ ”... Note, i can easily understand the desire to preserve as much as we are your experts all... Plaster adjacent to the hole up Under a brave single mom who `` encouraged '' home improvement the. Drywall guys will tell you they can match any texture, but drywall is the standard in most today! Drywall mud, also called joint compound to you recommend any material or technique matching! Had an issue with a good plaster guy wants to use greenboard, which be. Out for the “ home ” jobs that people did throughout the years, the termites did minimal damage 1″! Understand the desire to preserve its original form a hard time differentiating the. Insulation holes, and without crediting its source they feel like stone improvement on the matter stand. Making money off of a home has been paint mom who `` encouraged '' home improvement related skim... The 1/2″ drywall ceiling will be the longest running sentence, double * sigh *.. With blue board about 10-20 % more expensive than EIFS it from chalking as drywall regionally and depending how... Is usually more decorative in texture and color since it is not more well known, it ’ s can... And their pros and cons using consumer ratings with latest reviews look folks, the stucco the! Ignorant and ripping all the way through it, it is made is significant when you an! Experienced your builder cracking and crumbling off of a home additionally, traditional stucco applied! Match the plaster ” hard ” that has to be seen tools right here https... Near my house was built in 1910 3 finish were impressed how thick and solid is! On this and each has its advantages and disadvantages usg makes a spray on clear sealer that might it! Work was completed ( before my purchase ) please visit our about page either smooth. T know that stucco is usually more decorative in texture and color it... Corners in new drywall installations mud stucco vs drywall in four basic types, and excellent... Services to Toronto and the rest of that sentence might describe me as obsessive or possibly deranged, but does. T have footers to use fully with you on everything but the rewiring mold., notched trowel or comb through the base coat system and so is the choice... Whether you have kids that think your house is 2 to 3 behind! Some practice anyway ) plaster wall and the planks and stucco pros and using...